The trial of Paul Hart - The Verdict
05/01/04 | Exclusive to LTLF

After two weeks discussing the evidence and deliberating their decision, the jury is ready to deliver their verdict. The judge requires only a majority decision between the jurors to pass sentence. If he is found guilty of being a bad manager, Paul Hart faces the sack and up to 10 years unemployment.

There is a hushed and tense silence as the judge enters the courtroom.

Usher: All rise!

Judge Robert Wollaton: Please bring in the jury.

The twelve jurors shuffle into their box rather nervously.

Would the chairman of the jury please tell the court how you find the defendant on the charge of being a bad manager?

Chairman of the jury: We find the defendant not guilty.

Gasps of shock and relief are heard around the courtroom in equal measure.

Judge: Is this a verdict you all agree on?

Chairman: No, we came to this decision by an 8 to 4 majority.

Judge: Very well. [Turns to the defendant] Paul Hart, you have been found not guilty of being a bad manager. You are free to leave and continue as manager of Nottingham Forest football club for the time being. I hope I don't see you before me again any time soon.

Paul Hart: Thank you, your honour.

Nigel Doughty: [Shouting from the public gallery] No! No! It's not fair!

Judge: Order! Order! Will you stop shouting!

Doughty: I demand justice! How else am I supposed to get rid of this man!?

Judge: [Sternly] Mr Doughty, if you do not desist in this disgraceful outburst I shall find you in contempt of court and you will spend the night in the cells!

Doughty: You can't do this to me! I will not tolerate this total injustice! I demand a retrial!!

Judge: [To the court stewards] Please remove this man immediately and place him in custody!

Doughty is dragged from the courtroom, kicking and screaming something about what is he going to tell Glenn Hoddle now?

Well, in all my years as a judge, I have never seen such disgraceful behaviour. This case is now closed. Mr Hart, you are free to leave. [Bangs his gavel forcefully]

The court rises and Hart steps down from the dock with a broad smile on his face.

How you found Paul Hart   Guilty (159) 36.3% Not guilty (279) 63.7% Total of votes: 438